A mother has successfully appealed against a decision by Family Court Judge Robin Tolson KC, who allowed her ex-partner—being investigated for rape—to have overnight contact with their three children.The father had admitted domestic abuse and coercive control, while the mother alleged rape.High Court Judge Michael Keehan overturned Tolson's dismissal of the police investigation into the rape allegations.Tolson, previously criticized for outdated views on rape, faced renewed scrutiny over his handling of the case.The mother's barrister argued Tolson's approach aligned with past controversial remarks, prompting calls for judicial review.

Tolson's decisions have been repeatedly challenged in the past six years, with senior judges finding his evidence analysis 'seriously flawed'.The case highlights ongoing concerns about judicial bias in domestic abuse cases, with over 90% of family court cases involving such allegations.The government has pledged to improve support for victims in private law proceedings.