This opinion article by Rachel Withers examines the recent public behaviour of Australian shadow treasurer Tim Wilson, focusing on a contentious appearance on the Today show.During the interview, Wilson debated Employment Minister Amanda Rishworth over Labor's proposed tax reforms.

The exchange became notably personal when Wilson reportedly responded angrily after Rishworth pointed out that he had previously advocated similar tax policy changes in his 2020 book, The New Social Contract.

According to the article, Wilson's book proposed an even more far-reaching tax overhaul than the reforms currently being pursued by the Labor government.

Withers argues that Wilson's reaction was unusually defensive and highlights comments in which he allegedly suggested that Rishworth should 'grow up' and 'get a breathalyser'.The article uses this incident as a starting point to question Wilson's recent political conduct and public communication style.

Rather than focusing primarily on the details of the tax policy debate, the piece centres on Wilson's demeanour and political judgement, suggesting that those around him may need to address concerns about his approach.The article is clearly presented as commentary and opinion rather than straight news reporting.

It reflects the author's concerns about Wilson's performance as shadow treasurer and references previous commentary questioning his suitability for senior economic leadership roles.

Overall, the piece discusses the political implications of Wilson's public behaviour and his response to criticism regarding policy positions that appear similar to reforms he had previously supported.