The article gathers readers’ comments on historian Ramachandra Guha’s piece, which argues that the Congress party lacks competent leadership.Many readers agree with Guha, lamenting the party’s over-reliance on the Gandhi family and noting that without them, Congress would face fragmented power centres.Some express disappointment at the lack of viable alternatives to Narendra Modi.Others, however, defend Modi, pointing out perceived biases in Guha’s argument and questioning the ethical track record of past Congress governments.

There are also critiques highlighting the emotional and community-driven nature of Indian politics, where cultural narratives and regional influences often overshadow policy-based leadership.

A few responses discuss the misuse of institutions against opposition parties and media manipulation, indicating the complexity of Indian political dynamics.

Overall, the comments reflect a mix of agreement, frustration, and critical evaluation of Guha’s assessment, illustrating the divided public opinion about the Congress party and leadership in India.